Woman comparing wishlist apps on a phone

Best Giftster Alternatives in 2026

Giftster has been around since 2009, and it shows. If you want Giftster alternatives that look like they were made this decade, share with one link, and do not ask your whole family to join a group first, this list is for you. We compared the apps people move to most often: WishGrid, GiftList, Elfster and Amazon Wish List.

Short answer: WishGrid is the pick for most families. It is free, works on iPhone, Android and the web, and nobody needs an account to see your list.

Why people look for a Giftster alternative

Giftster does its core job. People add wishes, family members mark items as bought, and the list owner does not see who bought what. The problems are everything around that.

It looks old

Giftster is a 2009 product, and the design never really left that era. Even after its redesign, the app looks a generation older than the newer wishlist apps. Reviewers have said the same thing for years. One App Store reviewer wrote that the interface “has not been visually updated after all these years” and that scrolling was “glitchy and jerky”. A wishlist is something you send to your family every Christmas and every birthday. It should not look like a settings page from 2012.

The UX is built around groups, not people

Giftster is group-first. To get the full value, your family creates a group, everyone joins, and everyone keeps a list inside it. That is a lot of setup before the first useful moment, especially when you only want to send one list to your mom.

The friction shows up in small places:

  • Secret Santa needs accounts. Every participant must sign up, and the group needs at least three approved members before you can draw names.
  • Guests fill in forms. Guests can reserve from public lists on the website, but they type in a name and an email address first.
  • Kids’ lists need child accounts. If you keep a child’s list as a normal list, you do not see what family members already bought. You must move it to a child account to see the item status.

None of this is broken. It is just more steps than a wishlist needs in 2026.

What a good Giftster alternative should do

We compared each app on the things that matter in December:

  • Share with one link. Grandparents should open the list without an account or an app.
  • Reservations. Family marks gifts as taken, so nobody buys the same gift twice.
  • Any store. Paste a link from Amazon, Etsy or a small local shop and get a clean preview.
  • Phone and web. The same list everywhere.
  • A modern design. Fast, clean and easy for every age.

Giftster alternatives compared

WishGrid GiftList Elfster Amazon Wish List Giftster
Modern design Yes Dated Dated Storefront Dated
View without account Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Items from any store Best coverage Yes Yes Amazon first Yes
Collaborative lists Yes Yes Group only No Group only
No group setup needed Yes Yes No Yes No
Secret Santa draw No Yes Yes No Yes

The best Giftster alternatives

WishGrid

WishGrid is what Giftster would look like if it started today. You make a list, paste links from any store, and send one link. Friends and family open it in the browser without an account. To reserve a gift, they make a free account, and everyone else then sees that the item is taken, so nobody buys duplicates. Each list can be public, friends only or private, and you can invite collaborators, so two parents can run one list for the kids together.

It works as a native app on iPhone and Android and as a web app, with the same list and the same look on every device. It is free and has no ads.

Best for: families who want a clean, modern wishlist that everyone can use without setup.

Tradeoffs: no built-in Secret Santa draw and no child accounts. If you need a draw, use any free name-draw tool and put each person’s WishGrid link next to their name.

GiftList

A universal wishlist with a browser extension and a built-in gift exchange. It is the closest match to Giftster on features, and the design feels just as dated.

Best for: people who build lists on a desktop browser and want a gift exchange in the same app.

Tradeoffs: a dated design, no managed accounts for kids or pets, and extra AI and shopping features that add clutter if you want a simple list.

Elfster

The Secret Santa specialist. Name drawing with exclusions works well for large groups, and wishlists come attached.

Best for: an office or friend-group Secret Santa where the draw is the main event.

Tradeoffs: it is as dated as Giftster, the mobile app feels clunky, and it has a long reputation for heavy promotional email.

Amazon Wish List

Built into Amazon and free. Easy if your family already shops there.

Best for: people who buy everything on Amazon.

Tradeoffs: items from other stores are an afterthought, and there are no collaborative lists. Since March 2026, third-party sellers can receive your address from public list orders. Read more in our Amazon Wish List alternatives guide.

Which one should you pick?

  • Most families: WishGrid. One link, no accounts for viewers, and a design your family will actually enjoy using.
  • You need a gift exchange in the same app: GiftList.
  • The Secret Santa draw is the whole point: Elfster, or keep Giftster for the draw only.
  • You only shop on Amazon: Amazon Wish List.

For the full field, including creator platforms, see our best wishlist apps comparison.

How to move from Giftster to WishGrid

The switch takes about ten minutes per list:

  1. Open your Giftster list and WishGrid side by side.
  2. Copy the product link of each item and paste it into a new WishGrid list. WishGrid pulls the image, title and price for you. On a phone, you can also use the Share button in the store app. See how to save items from any store.
  3. Set the list visibility to public, friends or private.
  4. Send the new link to your family, and tell them which list to use from now on.

Do it before Black Friday on November 27. Family members who shop the sales then buy from your new list, not the old one. Our Black Friday wishlist guide explains how to prepare a list for the sales.

If the whole family wants to keep lists together, read how to make a group wishlist with friends.

Switch from Giftster

Free, no ads, no account to view

Create my wishlist